Updated 11/18/2025
You’re planning out your big budget projects for the year, when you realize that postponing your roof to winter could save you some money. In fact, it could discount your total cost by 10-20%, according to NewEnglandMetalRoof.com. That’s up to $2,400 off a $12,000 roof, and that definitely sounds appealing.
But then you think—wait, roofs shouldn’t be replaced during the winter, right? Isn’t that just a scam by roofing companies to get more business during their slow months, knowing that the roof won’t last as long? At least, that's what you read on Reddit.
Here’s the truth: your roof can be replaced during winter without any damage to its performance. Like any other situation, though, there are pros and cons to a winter roof installation that you should be aware of. This article covers the difference between winter and summer roof replacements. We'll break down the pros and cons by material, timeline, and what's best for your home.
As a Platinum Preferred Contractor with Owens Corning, we have experience serving thousands of homeowners in Central Pennsylvania and Northern Indiana. We value the quality of our service above all else, and know how to make a winter installation safe and effective for your home.
You’ll learn:
Contrary to what Reddit might suggest, your home can get a new roof in any season. A metal roof can be installed year-round, and even shingle roofs can be installed during winter with the correct materials and steps. Homeowners shouldn't just go with the cheapest roofer, though. Contractors should understand their manufacturer's guidelines and make adjustments for weather conditions.
Most people assume that roofing shingles installed at temperatures below 40 degrees won't perform well, but that's not entirely true. Many manufacturers, like Owens Corning, note in their technical bulletins that you can install shingles in lower temperatures if additional requirements are met (such as proper nail placement, additional steps, and direct sunlight).
Owens Corning Duration shingles, for example, can be installed below 40 degrees while staying effective. A good contractor will be trained on how to properly install your shingles in both cold and hot temperatures, referencing their manufacturer's guidelines.
With proper planning and techniques, winter roof installations can still be safe and successful.
The peak season for roof replacement in Northern states is generally late spring through late fall. Roofing projects are ideal during this period of predictable, mild weather. However, winter also has its benefits for roof installations.
Summer falls into the ideal season for a roof replacement, so naturally, there are advantages to scheduling during this time. But homeowners should also be aware of the potential drawbacks.
The material of your roof plays a role in determining if a winter or summer roof replacement is best for you. Review your material below for any key seasonal disadvantages.
| Material | Winter | Summer |
| Asphalt Shingles | Asphalt stiffens in cold; nailing/sealing is slower. | Seals faster in heat but can be damaged during handling. |
| Metal Roofing | Screws used in place of adhesive; slippery when icy. | Standard installation with no material concerns. |
| Flat Roofing: EPDM, TPO, PVC |
Adhesives must stay warm to avoid leaks. Transport and storage planning are essential. | Standard installation with no material concerns. |
In comparison to other materials, metal roofs are best for installation during the winter. Temperatures do not impact metal roofing performance in the same way as it does for shingles or flat roofing. Metal roofs can also be installed over shingle roofs, reducing concerns about debris.
There is a significant safety concern associated with installing metal roofs, however. Frost is a greater concern for metal roofs compared to shingles, as it increases the risk of slipping hazards. Contractors should always come prepared with the correct equipment, such as roofing harnesses, to remain safe during installation.
When it comes to replacing a roof during winter, there are a lot of opinions. Here’s the honest truth from a roofing professional:
False. Shingle roofs can be replaced in cold temperatures, provided they follow the manufacturer's specifications. Metal roofs can be replaced if proper safety precautions are taken. Flat roofs can be replaced, provided the adhesive material is stored in a warm environment.
False. Shingles will seal in cold weather so long as they have direct sunlight and are properly installed with the correct products.
False. Although storing your shingles in a heated warehouse is ideal to reduce potential waste, it is not required or always feasible. Suppliers often will deliver shingles directly to the jobsite. Roofers must be cautious that shingles aren’t damaged as they separate the packs, but additional material is often ordered just in case.
Unfortunately, life often has its own agenda, regardless of careful planning and scheduling. Active leaks, storms, or impact damage can necessitate roof replacements. Homeowners can use temporary solutions such as tarping or repairs to tide them over until weather conditions improve.
You can avoid most emergencies by performing proper maintenance on your roof during the spring and fall. Gutters should be routinely cleared, and trees should have branches trimmed away from the roof's surface to prevent damage. Ideally, homeowners should have their roofs professionally inspected once a year to ensure there are no issues.
If you’re having difficulty weighing the pros and cons of different seasons for your roof project, a roofer can help. Jot down a list of seasonal questions to ask during your initial consultation. We recommend referencing two or three contractors before making your final decision.
You came here wondering if replacing your roof in winter was risky, and now you know it can be done safely. Homeowners often assume a summer roof replacement is best, but each season has its own pros and cons to consider.
When it comes to the cost of your roof, the season you choose is only one of many factors. Learn more about roof replacement costs in our 2025 Homeowners Guide.
At Equity Roofing, we specialize in safe, high-quality roofing all year long. We can help you make informed, budget-smart decisions that make the most sense for your home. Contact us with any questions you may have by visiting our website.